As parents, we never stop caring — and it's only natural to have concerns, especially in today’s world. With so much evolving around technology, it's important to consider how screens may be affecting our mental health. Thankfully, emerging research—particularly on teens—is giving us valuable insights. By exploring this knowledge, we can thoughtfully make adjustments in our homes to support not only our children and teens, but also ourselves. Developing healthy screen habits can be a powerful step toward nurturing our overall well-being.
What recent research says about screen time and teens
Key findings from new large studies
High screen time (non‑schoolwork) → worse physical, mental, sleep, and social‐emotional outcomes
A nationally representative U.S. study using data from NHIS‑Teen, 2021‑2023 (ages 12‑17) found that teens who spend 4 or more hours/day on non‑school screen time are much more likely to have:
About 50.4% of U.S. teens report 4+ hours/day non‑school screen use. CDC
Dose‑response relationships
Studies are increasingly showing that the more screen exposure (especially recreational), the worse the outcomes: more depressive symptoms, more anxiety, lower life satisfaction. Also, exceeding certain thresholds (which vary by age and by device/usage type) tends to correlate with steeper declines. Government of Canada+2arXiv+2
Mediating/moderating factors: sleep, physical activity, regular bedtimes
One recent study (from 2025) showed that associations between excessive screen time (e.g. 4+ hours) and mental health problems (anxiety, depression, behavior problems, ADHD) are partially mediated by lower physical activity, short or irregular sleep, and irregular bedtime routines. arXiv
Gender and age differences
Teenage girls seem especially affected by high social media/screen use in terms of sleep loss, mental health. For example, Twenge’s more recent work indicates that among 10th grade girls, a large percentage spend 7+ hours/day on social media, which corresponds with worse well‑being. NPR+1
Younger teens show different thresholds and sometimes may be more vulnerable to certain harms. Also, some studies distinguish outcomes by sex, showing stronger associations for depression/anxiety among girls. Government of Canada+1
Sleep loss is central to many downstream harms
Across studies, disrupted sleep (later bedtimes, shorter duration, lower quality, irregular schedules) is a consistent correlate of high screen time, and seems to be one of the more powerful pathways by which screen exposure is affecting mental health. STAT+2arXiv+2
Jonathan Haidt’s contributions: “The Anxious Generation”
Haidt’s 2024 book The Anxious Generation: How the Great Rewiring of Childhood Is Causing an Epidemic of Mental Illness frames a narrative built on many of the findings that Twenge and others have been documenting. Key aspects:
He argues that smartphones/social media constitute a kind of “rewiring” of childhood, fundamentally altering how adolescents spend time, develop socially, attend to tasks, etc. Wikipedia+2Axios+2
Haidt identifies four foundational harms of what he calls the “phone‑based childhood”:
- Social deprivation — less time spent in in‑person social interaction, more isolation. The Hub+1
- Sleep deprivation — phones and social media interfering with needed sleep. ABC+1
- Attention fragmentation — constant interruptions, pings, multitasking, etc., reducing sustained focus. The Guardian+1
- Behavioral addiction — compulsive use, habitual checking, difficulty disengaging. The Guardian+1
He also points out that these harms are exacerbated when screen time crowds out other healthy activities — sleep, free play, physical exercise, face‑to‑face relationships. Axios+1
Haidt's recommended remedies include things like: delaying exposure to social media, restricting smartphone ownership/use until older ages, phone bans during school, no devices in bedrooms, more unstructured free play and independence for youth. ABC+1
Jean M. Twenge: Key points and recent findings
Twenge has been prominent in doing empirical work and synthesis on how screen time → mental health over time. Some highlights:
- As social media and smartphones have become more ubiquitous (especially after ~2010), many indicators of mental health (anxiety, depression, suicidal ideation) among adolescents have worsened. NPR+2Axios+2
- The rise in high‑intensity social media users: for example, Twenge reports that as of recently, 22% of 10th grade girls are spending 7 or more hours/day on social media. NP
- Correspondingly, sleep has dropped: between 2010 and 2021, the proportion of 10th and 12th graders sleeping 7 or fewer hours a night rose sharply. Twenge and colleagues argue adolescents biologically need ~9 hours, so less than 7 is well below healthy levels. NPR+2Government of Canada+2
- The Canadian research (2019 data) supports that meeting guidelines (≤ 2 hours/day recreational screen time) is associated with significantly better mental health outcomes, higher life satisfaction, less stress, etc. Government of Canada
Caveats, what we don’t yet know well
- Most studies are observational/correlational, so causation is harder to establish. For example, teens with depression might turn to screens more; also confounding factors (home environment, socioeconomic status, etc.) matter.
- The type of screen use matters: passive scrolling vs interactive communication vs gaming vs content type (violent, image heavy, compare‑oriented) likely differ in effects.
- Individual variability is high. Not every teen is harmed the same way; some show resilience, others are more vulnerable (by age, sex, existing mental health, social supports, etc.).
- We don’t yet fully understand long‑term trajectories: how early exposure sets up later risks (or resilience), what interventions are most effective, etc.
Twenge’s “10 Rules for Rising Kids in a High‑Tech World”
In her newest book 10 Rules for Raising Kids in a High‑Tech World: How Parents Can Stop Smartphones, Social Media, and Gaming from Taking Over Their Children’s Lives, Twenge lays out ten actionable rules for parents. From what’s publicly available, here are the rules, with brief explanations:
Rule 1. You’re in charge
Parents should take active leadership in setting boundaries with technology — it's not enough to just react. Parent sets the policy. jeantwenge.com
Rule 2. No electronic devices in the bedroom overnight
Remove or restrict screen devices from bedrooms during sleep hours to protect sleep quality and emotional wellbeing. jeantwenge.com
Rule 3. No social media until 16 — or later
Delay exposure to social media platforms until mid‑teenage years when teens are more psychologically robust to handle comparison, peer pressure, etc. jeantwenge.com
Rule 4. First phones should be basic phones
When giving a teen their first phone, choose something that can call/text but lacks full internet/social functionality. jeantwenge.com
Rule 5. Give the first smartphone with the driver’s license
Tie getting a full‑feature smartphone to a milestone (such as getting to drive), both for maturity and responsibility. jeantwenge.com
Rule 6. Use parental controls
Make use of settings and technical tools to limit screen content, usage time, notifications, etc. jeantwenge.com
Rule 7. Create no‑phone zones
Designate certain times or places (bedroom, dinner table, family activities) where phones are not allowed or used. jeantwenge.com
Rule 8. Give your kids real‑world freedom
Encourage independence, in‑person interaction, physical activity, unstructured play — allow teens to experience and learn beyond the virtual. jeantwenge.com
Rule 9. Beware the laptop — and the gaming console, and the tablet, and …
Be mindful of all devices; screen time isn't only about phones and social media. Gaming consoles, tablets, etc., also contribute. Monitor and limit accordingly. jeantwenge.com
Rule 10. Advocate for no phones during the school day
Push for policies in schools that limit phone use (or ban it during school hours) to protect attention, learning, and reduce distractions. jeantwenge.com
Putting it together: What this means for teens & families
- Thresholds matter: There is evidence that 4+ hours/day non‑school screen time is a kind of tipping point for many adverse outcomes. But even lower amounts (2‑3 hrs) can start to show associations, especially when screen use interferes with sleep or displaces physical activity or in‑person social interaction.
- Sleep is one of the most critical levers: Because many negative outcomes are mediated by poor sleep (too little sleep, irregular sleep, screen exposure before bed), improving sleep routines is likely to provide substantial benefit.
- Delaying exposure and increasing regulation helps: Both Twenge and Haidt agree that delaying access to social media, using basic phones early, restricting use during school/daytime, bans from bedrooms, etc., can mitigate harms.
- The quality of screen interactions matters: Not all screen use is harmful — video chatting with friends, creative or educational content, etc., may be less harmful or even beneficial. But platforms designed for maximizing engagement (scrolling, algorithmic content, notifications) tend to carry more risk.
- Policy level interventions are possible and important: Schools, communities, tech platforms, and regulation (of social media use, age rules, notifications, etc.) can make a difference. Haidt emphasizes structural changes (phone bans in schools, raising minimum ages, etc.) as part of the solution.
What to watch / recommendations
Here are some suggestions, drawn both from Twenge/Haidt research and public health studies, that might help in reducing risks and promoting healthier screen habits:
- Establish clear screen‑use rules early (e.g. no phones overnight, screen‑free dinner, etc.)
- Monitor and limit discretionary screen time (not for school/homework)
- Prioritize sleep hygiene: regular bedtimes, avoid screen exposure in the hour(s) before sleep
- Encourage physical activity, free play, time outdoors, and face‑to‑face social interactions
- Choose content carefully: limit highly addictive / comparison‑oriented social media use
- Use parental controls etc. to enforce or support boundaries
- Delay giving access to full social media, internet‑capable smartphones until teen years or later
- Advocate for institutional change: schools, peers, policy makers
Additional Resources:
NYTimes:
She Started the Debate About Kids and Phones. Now She Wants to End It https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/06/well/family/jean-twenge-social-media-screens-teens.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare
Books:
The Anxious Generation, Jonathan Haidt, 2024
iGen, Jean Twenge
10 Rules for Raising Kids in a High, Tech World, Jean Twenge, 2024
Connect with one of our Calgary therapists by clicking here to book a session or a free 15-minute consultation
Disclaimer:
The content contained in this post is for informational/educational purposes only. It is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, consultation, diagnosis, or treatment. Please seek the advice of your qualified mental healthcare provider in your area with any personal questions you may have.
Aspen Psychology Group is accepting clients at this time, Alberta residents can book an appointment here. Also, PsychologyToday.com is a great resource for finding a mental health professional in your area